Razing the Ghetto

It is inappropriate to compare Gaza with the Warsaw Ghetto which was created by Governor General Nazi Hans Frank in October 1940. Razing the ghetto commenced  on 18 January 1943 and lasted until April. Neither the size of the Warsaw Ghetto (3.4 as compared to 365 km2) nor its population (400,000 as compared to 1.7 million) nor the number of civilian casualties (at least 300,000 Polish Jews) fit. Purposeful extermination of the Jews in the ghetto was due to starvation, contagions and mass shootings while the people of Gaza are only put on diet, with 2279 calories a day far more than what German Nazis suggested for Polish Jews (184 calories a day), see further “red lines” of Israeli authorities here [pdf]. While the wall surrounding the Warsaw Ghetto was typically 3 m high, people in the “World’s largest open air prison” (as the Gaza strip has recently been described by Noam Chomsky) are contained by up to 9 m high walls.

While the Israelis have called their current assault on Gaza “Pillar of Defense” any comparisons with Adolf Hitler’s yelling “Seit 5.45 Uhr wird zurückgeschossen” when his assault on Poland unleashed World War II after the plotted Gleiwitz incident are inappropriate. Likewise, likening Hitler’s pretext to WWII with Iran being the real target these days is absolutely inappropriate.

Hitler’s strive for Lebensraum must not be compared with Israel’s occupation of Palestinian territory with its ongoing illegal settlements, constantly colonizing and stealing Palestinian land on the West Bank, and its blockage of the Gaza strip.

While Gaza is being razed these days, the 70th anniversary of the final destruction of Warsaw’s Ghetto is upcoming.

18 November 2012 @ 8:18 am.

Last modified November 18, 2012.

Posted in Israel, Palestine | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Pillar of Defense

Noam Chomsky, who had been visiting Tromsø University in September this year, managed a couple of weeks ago to enter Gaza, where he attended a linguistic conference at the Islamic University, for the first time in his life. He had to enter from Egypt (where he was later guest at the American University in Cairo) since Israel of course  denied access to the strip under its blockade. Gaza Islamic University awarded Chomsky (a true pillar of defense of Palestinian rights) with an honorary doctorate for his “efforts for truth and freedom in Palestine.” Interviewed in Gaza, Chomsky repeated his warning against an academic boycott of Israel which he had also expressed when in Tromsø.

“If you call for an academic boycott of say Tel Aviv University you have to ask yourself, what the consequences are of that call for the Palestinians and there’s an indirect answer. When you carry out an act in the United States, you are trying to reach the American population and you’re trying to bring the American population to be more supportive of Palestinian rights and opposed to Israeli and US policies.

So you therefore ask yourself, will an academic boycott of Tel Aviv University have – you ask yourself what the effect would be on the American audience in the United States that you are trying to reach. Now, that depends on the amount of organization and education that has taken place in the United States.

Today, if you look at the people’s understandings and beliefs, a call for an academic boycott on Tel Aviv University will strengthen support for Israel and US policy because it’s not understood. There is no point of talking to people in Swahili if they don’t understand what you are saying. There could be circumstances in which a boycott of Tel Aviv would be helpful, but first you have to do the educational and organizational work.”

A couple of days before the critical situation in Gaza is now being escalated by Israel after having assassinated Hamas military leader Ahmad al-Jabari on Wednesday this week (the new operation has got already a name, Pillar of Defense), Chomsky has given a disconcerting account of his visit at truthdig.com, where he writes about the “World’s largest open-air prison”.

Four years after then Prime Minster Ehud Olmert had raided the strip in what is now called Operation Cast Lead (more than 1000 Palestinians, including 926 civilians, and 13 Israelis were killed), the same seems to happen again under similar pretense. And again shortly after US American President Obama’s (re-)election. This time, the upcoming war is carefully popularized by Israels’ Defense Force though.

16 November 2012 @ 9:25 am.

Last modified November 16, 2012.

Posted in Academics, Israel, Palestine | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Not Allowed to Communicate With the Press

According to Paula Broadwell talking on October 26 at University of Denver about her biography and having been asked by someone in the auditorium to talk about the Benghazi disaster where U.S. Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other Americans were killed, General David Petraeus in his new position as CIA Director was “not allowed to communicate with the press” when, as was broken the very same day by Fox News’ Jennifer Griffin, the “urgent request from the CIA annex for military back-up during the attack on the U.S. consulate [in Benghazi on September 11] and subsequent attack several hours later on the annex itself was denied by the CIA chain of command — who also told the CIA operators twice to “stand down” rather than help the ambassador’s team.”

What Broadwell then disclosed, just ten days before Election Day, was that Petraeus of course knew within 24 hours that the attack was not about the anti-Muhammad video, the Obama administration had tried to claim.

“Now, I don’t know if a lot of you have heard this but the CIA annex had actually taken a couple of Libyan militia members prisoner, and they [Petraeus and administration officials] think that the attack on the consulate was an effort to try get these prisoners back, so that’s still being vetted.”

Broadwell’s leak about possibly true motives of the attackers may be revealing as regards her own motives. Immediately after his inauguration in January 2009, Obama had ordered secret interrogation camps abroad to be closed. So what was the role of the “CIA annex” closely related to the Consulate in Benghazi? According to Broadwell, “the challenge has been the fog of war, and the greater challenge is that it’s political hunting season, and so this whole thing has been turned into a very political sort of area.”

So, is Petraeus’ downfall in fact rooted in jealousy? It is hoped that Petraeus does actually have the balls to testify before Congress about the Benghazi disaster as requested.

12 November 2012 @ 10:26 am

Last modified November 12, 2012.

Posted in USA | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Rules for Living

Rather than explaining to the public early why he had to resign as CIA Director, General David Petraeus, once President Obama’s “czar of drone warfare  in Afghanistan” and in fact becoming later the “King of Drones”, had entertained just one day before Election Day his lessons on leadership. Guess who had interviewed him? Well, his biographer Paula Broadwell, who has been under FBI investigations for getting access to Petraeus’ private email account and is said to be the main reason for his sudden resignation, though he was already under fire after the Benghazi Consulate disaster on September 11.

So, Broadwell lists twelve well-known rules for leaders.

“1. Lead by example from the front of the formation. Take your performance personally—if you are proud to be average, so too will be your troops.

2. A leader must provide a vision—clear and achievable ‘big ideas’ combined in a strategic concept—and communicate those ideas throughout the entire organization and to all other stakeholders.

3. A leader needs to give energy; don’t be an oxygen thief.

4. There is an exception to every rule, standard operating procedure, and policy; it is up to leaders to determine when exceptions should be made and to explain why they made them.

5. We all will make mistakes. The key is to recognize them and admit them, to learn from them, and to take off the rear-view mirrors—drive on and avoid making them again.

6. Be humble. The people you’ll be leading already have on-the-ground conflict experience. ‘Listen and learn.’

7. Be a team player. ‘Your team’s triumphs and failures will, obviously, be yours.’ Take ownership of both.

8. Don’t rely on rank. If you rely on rank, rather than on the persuasiveness of your logic, the problem could be you and either your thinking or your communication skills. Likewise, sometimes the best ideas come from bottom-up information sharing (i.e., ‘Need to share’ not ‘Need to know’). Use ‘directed telescopes’ to improve situational awareness.

9. Leaders should be thoughtful but decisive. Listen to subordinates’ input, evaluate courses of action and second- and third-order effects, but be OK with an ’80 per­cent solution.’ ‘There will be many moments when all eyes turn to you for a decision. Be prepared for them. Don’t shrink from them. Embrace them.’ Some­times the best move is the bold move.

10. Stay fit to fight. Your body is your ultimate weapons system. Physical fitness for your body is essential for mental fitness.

11. The only thing better than a little competition is a lot of competition. Set challenges for your subordinates to encourage them to excel.

12. Everyone on the team is mission critical. Instill in your team members a sense of great self-worth—that each, at any given time, can be the most important on the battlefield.”

Well, love is a battlefield, too. See General Petraeus’ resignation letter here.

10 November 2012 @ 08:42 am.

Last modified November 10, 2012.

Posted in USA | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Drone Incident November 1

Not only Iranians are concerned about re-elected President Obama’s expanding drone war  in right now five countries. Iran is already a target.

In order to get an idea where the American predator drone (fortunately “unarmed”, as CNN broke yesterday after the incident had been disclosed by the Pentagon just one day after the election) had been shot at on November 1, the Washington Post has a map of the respective corner of the Persian Gulf where the 12 mile zone is marked which allegedly had not been violated by the drone.

The drone was possibly shot at offshore the Bushehr nuclear plant (see the 12 mile nautical sovereignty distance in red). The drone was not hit, so one may assume a warning shot.

9 November 2012 @ 9:39 am.

Last modified November 9, 2012.

Posted in Iran, USA | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment