Genocide Decision By the ICJ

That the International Court of Justice judged before yesterday that Myanmar committed genocide when murdering and expelling its Rohingya minority in 2016 and 2017 is historic. The court found ‘intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population’, i.e the necessary dolus specialis.

This will inevitably have consequences how the World will see a still pending case of South Africa’s Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip (South Africa v. Israel).

I have written about my stance in that case and my unwillingness to follow most left-leaning and progressive media worldwide which hold it for granted that Israel commits genocide in Gaza as dolus specialis is extremely difficult to prove.

If the ICJ would have come to a different conclusion in the Myanmar case, the pending case of South Africa v. Israel would most probably be dead. So, there is hope that the panel of judges in Den Haag will eventually (not before 2030) come to the right verdict.

In an interview with SPIEGEL Online, International Law Professor Kai Ambos said (machine-translated),

[A] verdict in this case [South Africa v. Israel] is unlikely before 2030. But, of course, the ruling on Myanmar will set a precedent for Gaza. There are certainly parallels between the way the Myanmar military has conducted warfare and the actions of the Israeli army in Gaza. Myanmar argued that it was fighting terrorists—a line of reasoning similar to Israel’s. The judges responded that while this may be true, it does not necessarily rule out genocidal intent. Likewise, the fact that Israel claims to conduct its military operations in accordance with the rules of international humanitarian law—regardless of whether that is actually the case—does not, in itself, preclude genocidal intent.

Asked, by Spiegel Online, “Even if the ICJ were to determine one day that no genocide took place in Gaza, would that necessarily amount to an acquittal?”, he answered,

A ruling regarding Israel would likely read much the same as the one concerning Myanmar. In that sense, whether or not genocide is found to have occurred is almost secondary. That is why many argue that, in cases like these, we shouldn’t focus so heavily on genocide—because doing so obscures the fact that the other acts involved also constitute very serious crimes. (Emphasis added.)

21 November 2026 @ 16:11 UTC+1.

Last modified November 21, 2026.

This entry was posted in Israel, Palestine, South Africa and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply